Which Toaster to Buy? The Very Toaster Buying Guide

The humble toaster has been a kitchen essential since it was first invented over a hundred years ago, and it’s still everyone’s go-to appliance when you need to feed the family. No matter whether it’s a hectic breakfast rush, or those times when you fancy a slice of hot, buttered toast to get you through to the next mealtime! 

With so many options to choose from on the market, our Very Tech team has created this handy Toaster Buying Guide to run you through all the important features and personal factors to bear in mind. From budget 2-slice models to high-spec top-end toasters with all the features, we can help you find the perfect match for your kitchen counter. 

What to Consider When Buying a Toaster

The best toasters combine reliability and versatility, ensuring consistent results whether you’re toasting a sliced loaf, home-cut bread, bagels or crumpets. From the width of bread to your preferred level of crunch, let’s get into the important factors to bear in mind when making your choice.

Slot Size

This is important in terms of both the length of your bread and the thickness. If you’re a fan of well buttered white toast with a fry-up then you need to be sure the slots are long enough to fit a slice of Warburtons bread. For those who prefer a more artisanal approach, you might consider an extra-wide slot size to accommodate bagels and hand-cut slices.

2-Slice Vs 4-Slice Toaster

A 4-slice toaster is essential if you want family breakfasts to pass peacefully. They may take up more space on your counter, but they’ll ensure everyone gets fed quickly with a lot less squawking! Dual control models are great for those times when you only need two slots - not heating the other two slots will help keep your electricity costs down. A 2-slice toaster saves on space in smaller households.

Browning Control

Just like your holiday tan, nobody wants a patchy result. A universal golden-brown hue is what we’re after, done exactly as dark or light as you prefer and all ready to absorb the butter or margarine perfectly! Adjusting the browning level simply alters the amount of time the bread is exposed to the heating element, rather than increasing the heat, so it’s all about waiting slightly longer.

Power

The higher the wattage of your toaster, the greater the power and the faster it will toast your bread. A lower wattage toaster takes more time and the results can be slightly more chewy than crunchy. Look for 1000 watt or above for a 2-slice toaster and 1800 watt or higher for a 4-slice machine to achieve a decent crunch and avoid too much hanging about.

Ease of Cleaning

An easy-to-remove crumb tray is essential for keeping your toaster clean and hygienic, as well as helping to avoid those nasty burnt smells in your kitchen! A good 4-slice toaster will have separate crumb trays, enabling you to quickly clean one or both of them as required, though a weekly spruce-up is recommended if you use your toaster on a daily basis. When it comes to maintaining the exterior, it’s good to avoid a toaster that shows up every fingerprint – and don’t forget to regularly wipe away crumbs from the top.

Life Expectancy

The average lifespan of a toaster is around 4 to 8 years, depending on the quality of its heating elements and pop-up mechanism - not to mention how well it’s cared for of course! While premium models or smart toasters will often last longer, paying more doesn’t always guarantee greater longevity—especially if regular cleaning is neglected. Keeping the crumb tray empty and the toaster well-maintained can make a big difference in how long it keeps delivering that perfect golden slice.

Style

Not many people put their toaster away in the cupboard after use (unlike their toastie maker!), so for most of us it’s permanently out on display. That means the design is always going to be important. Thankfully, the days of utilitarian looks are gone, and you're now able to choose from all sorts of shapes and styles to suit the aesthetic of your kitchen. Here at Very you'll find a toaster for every taste, from 50s-inspired versions to ultra-modern models that will instantly take centre stage on your counter!

Colour

Just as important as style is colour, and you can also pick from a versatile palette to ensure your toaster complements its surroundings, whether you're going for a contemporary apartment appearance or a traditional country cottage vibe. Want to make things even more eye-catching? There are also tantalising toaster designs that feature bold patterns - perfect for the most modern of kitchens! For the best co-ordinated look, we recommend checking out the matching toaster and kettle sets.

Toaster Features

More expensive toasters often come with handy extra features, which you might want to take into consideration. So, let’s look at the options, starting with the standard features you always get with any toaster and moving onto the optional extras (that are essentials to some).

The Basics

The Optional Extras

Best Toasters

After careful testing and consideration, we’re delighted to announce our best buy toaster category winners! We’ve looked high and low for the best toasters and have split our recommendations into 9 categories based on what customers prioritise as the most important features. Deciding what is the best toaster on the market today is very much about your individual priorities when it comes to feeding yourself and your family, so looking through our winners should help you find the perfect match for your kitchen. 

Best 2-Slice Toaster

Bosch DesignLine 2-Slice Toaster

Specifications 

  • 6 browning levels with clearly marked dial 

  • Automatic bread centring 

  • High-lift function 

  • Comes with warming rack 

  • Easy-clean crumb tray 

  • Automatic shut-off if bread gets stuck 

If you want to know what makes a good 2-slice toaster, look no further than Bosch for the answer! Featuring that famous German build quality, the DesignLine Toaster offers reliability and a compact, sleek design that squeezes in some handy extra features.

Best 4-Slice Toaster

Dualit Architect Brushed Stainless Steel 4-Slice Toaster

Specifications 

  • Extra-wide 36mm slots 

  • Perfect Toast technology 

  • Pop & Peek feature 

  • Dual controls 

  • Bagel setting only toasts one side 

  • Interchangeable colour panels available 

  • Can be co-ordinated with Architect kettle 

When it comes to build quality, you can’t beat the Dualit Architect. This British company are highly respected for the longevity of their products, so you know you’re ready for the long haul. The toasting performance is equally reliable thanks to Dualit's Perfect Toast technology, which assesses the temperature of the toaster and its surroundings, then adjusts the toasting cycle to ensure perfect results every time.

Best Budget Toaster 

Salter Toronto 4-Slice Toaster

Specifications 

  • 4 wide slots for bagels, crumpets and thick slices of bread 

  • 6 browning levels give just the right level of crunch

  • 2 control dials let you control each side separately

  • Crumb tray for easy cleaning

  • High-lift eject function

  • Defrost and reheat settings

  • Can be matched with other items

Great value, the Salter Toronto 4-Slice Toaster makes it affordably easy to bring extra modern style to your kitchen worktop.

Best Designed Toaster 

Smeg 2-Slice Toaster 

Specifications  

  • Beautifully designed with premium enamel finish 

  • Illuminated controls 

  • 6 levels of browning 

  • Bagel function 

  • Self-centring racks 

  • Easy clean crumb tray 

  • Sandwich rack and bun warmer available 

  • 2-year standard Smeg warranty 

Smeg's iconic 1950s retro design comes in a choice of beautiful colours, all with a premium enamelled finish. It makes a real statement piece on your kitchen counter, especially if partner it up with the matching Smeg Kettle.

Best Browning Toaster 

Sage The Smart Toast 4-Slice Toaster 

Specifications  

  • Press a button for automatic lowering 

  • LEDs indicate toasting progress 

  • A Quick Look function 

  • Dual controls 

  • Extra-wide slots 

  • A Bit More button 

  • Crumpet/Fruit Loaf function 

  • Easy-clean crumb tray 

If you’re very specific about how you like your toast, then it’s worth thinking about investing in Sage’s The Smart Toaster. It isn’t the cheapest on the market but what you get is a host of clever features that ensure it browns both sides perfectly evenly every time, regardless of whatever you’re toasting.

Best Wide Slot Toaster 

Breville Aura 4-Slice Toaster 

 Specifications  

  • Extra wide variable width slots 

  • High Lift function 

  • Illuminated control panel 

  • Lift & Look function 

  • Easy-clean crumb tray 

  • Internal cord storage 

The extra wide slots of the Breville Aura 4-Slice Toaster are designed to comfortably fit all your hefty, homecut slices and plump, doughy bagels.

Best for Toasting Frozen Bread 

Dualit 40352 Vario 4-Slice Toaster   

Specifications  

  • Handmade in the UK 

  • Repairable, replaceable parts 

  • Ejector lever lets you check toasting mid-cycle 

  • Slot-selector control lets you use one side only

  • Mechanical timer  

  • High Lift mechanism 

  • Easy-clean crumb tray 

When it comes to quality, you can’t beat a toaster hand-built here in the UK, with the assembler's name to be found on the base. Now that’s personal service!

Best Compact Toaster 

Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press 

Specifications  

  • 7 functions - Toast, Bagel, Defrost, Grill, Panini, Bake, and Reheat 

  • Long, wide slot fits 2 slices of bread 

  • 7 toasting levels 

  • Grill mode 

  • Includes Panini Press and Baking Tray 

The Ninja Foodi 3-in-1 Toaster, Grill & Panini Press packs in a whole lot of value. It serves as a traditional toaster in upright mode, with room for 2 slices of bread in the extra-wide slot, but can also be turned on its side for use as a sandwich press and grill.

Best Toaster & Kettle Set  

Smeg 50s Retro Style Kettle & 4-Slice Toaster

Specifications  

  • Beautifully designed with premium enamel finish 

  • Self-centring toaster slots 

  • 1.7-litre kettle with soft opening lid 

  • 2-year standard Smeg warranty 

This double header of Smeg's iconic retro design will enhance any kitchen. There’s a choice of beautiful colours, all with a premium enamelled finish, so you can find the look that best suits your home décor.

Raise a toast!

Congratulations, now that we've got the essentials covered, you're all set to pick out the perfect toaster for you and your family. With fuss-free delivery straight to your door, plus VeryPay’s flexible payment options and Very Protect to cover your toaster against accidental damage from day one, the only difficult choice you'll have to make is whether to put jam or marmalade on that next buttered slice!

FAQs